Rhein-Main

In 1977 German players were admitted and a German club called "Rhein-Main" was established. The politically correct "GC Rhein-Main/Rheinblick Course" is certainly a mouthful, but the rather shorter moniker of "Rheinbrick" fell out of use since fairway irrigation was installed in a massive "millennium update". Not quite as comprehensive, but just as well received was David Krause's renovation in 2013.

Much like Augusta National the course was built on heavily undulated, but fairly open land and subsequent tree plantings have changed its character substantially. Nevertheless, Rheinblick still offers a glimpse of how Alister MacKenzie's masterpiece might have played in its formative years: very firm from tee to green, solid strategic options and a smattering of ground game throughout.

The routing succeeds on several fronts. First, it provides a great mixture of long and short holes, of narrow and wide fairways and the best green sites were reserved for the par threes. Second, it levels the playing field. Long hitters have a few opportunities to cut doglegs and bomb the occasional driver. The par fives are mostly reachable in two, but other than that, short and accurate players can easily stand their ground. Especially when they're good putters, because even solid ball strikers will struggle to create enough spin on the very firm and undulated greens. Most of the collars are cut relatively short, too, although not to fairway height. Third, the routing cares for walkers and fourth, average hitters off the members' tee can reach most holes in regulation.

As for any tree-lined course, there will be balls in the woods and tree management is a constant challenge. But despite a number of hanging fairways a good shot will not disappear in the forest and a bad shot is often retrievable. Fans of quirky tracks will love the experience, perhaps for different reasons, but just as much as competitive golfers.

It's a truly American venue in the best sense of the word.